Apple has a Rivle and Things get Settled:

I read an article about apple settleing things with it's rivel and it talked about a patent that was first granted to the company CReative they called it the ZEn patent. In the end Creative won because they had the Zen patent first for the new idea that Apple had tried to get patented a little while a fter Creative. The zen patent was about the menus u can go through to pick u'r artists, song, and then play then or other things and choises that the iPod includes. So it was all settled with Creative making accesories for Apple and they also get shears from Apple.